Search:
search button
I really need salary help!!
 
3 posts
05.08.8
Applying from new york for London
 
3 posts
06.08.8
Applying from new york for London
 
3 posts
04.08.8
Why Is Consulting So Tough?
 
4 posts
02.08.8
Advice Required.
 
4 posts
05.08.8
Best Industry Employers for Procurement Specialist
 
7 posts
09.08.8
Detica sale...
 
20 posts
05.08.8
Healthcare, pharmaceutical
 
2 posts
02.08.8
AT Kearney Upstream Practice
 
1 posts
31.07.8
Manufacturing
 
5 posts
04.08.8
Merger of Bain and Roland Berger?
 
7 posts
24.02.9
Any good - iMpower?
 
1 posts
31.07.8
KPMG IT Advisory Final Round Assessment Day
 
4 posts
03.08.8
If you worked in industry...
 
2 posts
31.07.8
MSc from top Uni to improve chances?
 
6 posts
01.08.8
Downsizing
 
9 posts
31.07.8
IT Cons. to Management Cons.
 
6 posts
31.07.8
Grad. Offer
 
2 posts
30.07.8
Which is the best stream to enter?
 
4 posts
31.07.8
Contacting Alumni
 
4 posts
31.07.8
Networking and New Business
 
4 posts
29.07.8
Consultancies interested in Ex- Military
 
3 posts
29.07.8
PWC package
 
4 posts
30.07.8
Perot Systems
 
1 posts
29.07.8
CapGemini Salary C3/C4
 
1 posts
29.07.8
EX Pat Packagesfor consultants in the Gulf esp.Dubai/ Bahrain / Qatar-
 
5 posts
30.07.8
ATOS ORIGIN procurement consultants
 
1 posts
29.07.8
advice for a newbie please
 
2 posts
29.07.8
How to avoid burning bridges?
 
9 posts
28.07.8
Who are they?
 
12 posts
29.07.8
Siddall & Company?
 
2 posts
28.07.8
Consulting work-life balance
 
11 posts
30.07.8
Validation of business models for a start up diagnostics
 
1 posts
28.07.8
Roland Berger Strategy Consultants in the US
 
5 posts
31.07.8
ZB is back!
 
9 posts
28.07.8
A client complains………
 
5 posts
26.07.8
How to get into consulting
 
2 posts
26.07.8
IBM TSM pay bands and salary
 
4 posts
05.08.8
The failure of the meritocracy
 
5 posts
30.07.8
Is it worth spending your evening on MBA?
 
13 posts
24.07.8
Bain
 
18 posts
01.09.8
Motiviert im Job?
 
2 posts
24.07.8
Dragging out assignments
 
5 posts
25.07.8
Smaller strategy firms
 
4 posts
28.07.8
Opportunities Abroad?
 
1 posts
24.07.8
Agents - Your opinion
 
1 posts
23.07.8
Accenture and Efficio
 
5 posts
24.07.8
Like Consulting / Hate Travel
 
16 posts
30.07.8
atk or ...?what level and how?
 
2 posts
27.07.8
Best at Operations Conulting?
 
23 posts
03.10.9
 

The failure of the meritocracy

 
forum comment
#0 The failure of the meritocracy
 
shakesonaplane
24.07.8 00:00
 
Consultancy – the last bastion of meritocracies. Or so I thought.Promotions are in the air, so the young analysts are abuzz with the potential for salary increases, new business cards, and the hope that they may be able to go get a mortgage.Well, my young analyst friends, the air should not be abuzz, as it reeks of bullshit and ceremony. You are not being promoted because of your good work on that competitive market analysis, nor for the extra 800 hours you worked last year (averaging your salary lower than what you were making at your last summer job). You are being promoted (or not) due to the bullshit time based ladder climb.I can understand the time based ladder climb in offices where none of the analysts are grads from top B-schools across the country, but that is not the case where I hang my coat and flirt with the admin assistants. I am constantly impressed by the quality of work and dedication shown by new entrants to the firm.So why am I so choked up about this? I am of the Church of Adam Smith. The Wealth of Nations is my bible. Meritocracy is my religion. “The extent of your participation will be the measure of your reward” is my motto.This sort of gerontocracy is appalling for two main reasons: * We are forever competing with other firms for work. Why not put our best people forward? * “Doing your time” is not a legitimate career pathIn fact, Consultancy is starting to remind me of the Union environment - except unions have communists fighting for shorter working weeks, less stringent sexual harassment laws, and free drugs to help keep the delusion going.http://shakesonaplane.wordpress.com/
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: The failure of the meritocracy
 
Anon
24.07.8 00:00
 
Someone just missed promotion then..?
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: The failure of the meritocracy
 
anon
24.07.8 00:00
 
I think half the problem is that markets aren't actually truly competitive. If they were, then half those public sector leech organisations would be out of business by now. But sadly they keep on going - on my tax money!
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: RE: The failure of the meritocracy
 
Hair
24.07.8 00:00
 
There would have to be a meritocracy for it to fail
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: The failure of the meritocracy
 
below peer group
30.07.8 00:00
 
absolutely agree original poster. i joined as an exp hire and am easily a couple of levels below what i should be. so, either sit out another 2-3 yrs to make the grade i should have been in the first place or.......join the consulting merry go-round :)
 
Reply

Reply

 
Return to the top of page.

ThreadID: 0