Search:
search button
London Based Technology Consulting
 
4 posts
22.07.8
BCG case studies
 
3 posts
17.07.8
Business Modelling, BIG 4
 
4 posts
16.07.8
Is consulting dumbing down?
 
21 posts
18.07.8
FAO: IT Consultants
 
6 posts
14.07.8
General Q about consultancy
 
4 posts
15.07.8
How good is good?
 
7 posts
16.07.8
Norconsult, Telconsult
 
1 posts
12.07.8
Eurogroup Consulting Alliance
 
8 posts
16.07.8
Blue chip vs Boutique - is bigger better?
 
5 posts
11.07.8
Anybody new to PwC PIC at associate level?
 
19 posts
04.08.8
Habits and selection
 
9 posts
11.07.8
Consulting after FMCG + MBA
 
3 posts
10.07.8
Irritating colleague
 
6 posts
10.07.8
The Frugal Lifestyle
 
3 posts
08.07.8
Car Allowance Survey
 
19 posts
09.07.8
Making the move into VC - crazy right now?
 
7 posts
08.07.8
marakon?
 
2 posts
08.07.8
KPMG IT Advisory salaries
 
5 posts
12.07.8
Temp work
 
1 posts
07.07.8
What to do?
 
89 posts
08.03.11
Been turned away by Big 4. What next?
 
10 posts
06.08.8
Get a grip - consultants aren't evil!
 
23 posts
04.08.8
Ops DD -where can it go?
 
6 posts
17.07.8
Consultant grades at Accenture
 
12 posts
11.07.8
Aftershave advice
 
10 posts
08.07.8
Angels or Charlatans? What has been your experience with external consultants?
 
3 posts
07.07.8
Career Focus
 
7 posts
07.07.8
Conspiracy theories
 
8 posts
08.07.8
Question for Oracle/ERP consultants
 
4 posts
07.07.8
MC grad scheme (experience)
 
2 posts
04.07.8
Datamonitor Assesssment Day
 
3 posts
14.07.8
Employment contract doth not a summer make
 
3 posts
07.07.8
Cheap advice is bad advice
 
8 posts
07.07.8
PwC Performance Improvement Consultancy - CIPS
 
7 posts
07.07.8
Occupational Psychology
 
9 posts
10.07.8
Web Conference / Remote Support
 
2 posts
04.07.8
This forum
 
8 posts
07.07.8
Stay or go to make consultant?
 
6 posts
04.07.8
Referrals
 
2 posts
09.08.8
EXPERIENCED HIRE: AM I DREAMING?
 
3 posts
02.07.8
Contact for BAS F&PM recruitment?
 
4 posts
03.07.8
External consulting to 'internal consulting' role in industryand back again?
 
5 posts
02.07.8
Not the same old questions
 
8 posts
03.07.8
Payrises this year
 
20 posts
08.07.8
Summer Internships
 
3 posts
01.07.8
Reccomended qualifications for a fresher
 
5 posts
27.06.8
Urgent Internship
 
17 posts
09.07.8
MC to IB move possible?
 
18 posts
02.07.8
the economy
 
2 posts
26.06.8
 

How good is good?

 
forum comment
#0 How good is good?
 
Anon
13.07.8 00:00
 
Hi guys,I'm a recent graduate who is thinking of applying for MBBB and a few second tier strat consultancies. Everyone says that you really have to be exceptional to get offered a place but how good is good?I graduated from an (arguably) top 5 uni with a first in Engineering. I speak native English + 1 other European language (fluent not native). I'm working on a third language at the moment and hope to have a good knowledge before I taking up a position.I also have reasonably good (not amazing) extra curriculars. I don't want to go into too much detail in case I can be identified.Work: Internship with big 4 + 4-5 other roles with various other smaller non consultancy companies.Well, am I in with a chance?
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: How good is good?
 
anon
13.07.8 00:00
 
Suppose, I'd better point out my own typo before I get crucified by the grammar hounds! It should read:good knowledge before taking up a position.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: How good is good?
 
Bnon
13.07.8 00:00
 
On the face of it, yes you could be considered at application sift stage. This assumes that your written communication skills are also exceptional and that you apply them to your CV and covering letter. Based on the (admittedly limited) evidence of your initial post, you should be okay.Beyond the initial sift stage, specific factors, competencies, experiences and skills come into play that I unfortunately can't give you feedback on with only the information in your question. Those assessments are based on information at a "personally identifiable" level of granularity, plus impressions that can only be formed in face-to-face situations.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: How good is good?
 
anon
14.07.8 00:00
 
Thanks, anyone think otherwise?
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: How good is good?
 
Mark
15.07.8 00:00
 
Submit your details & find out!Somewhat cynically, I'd suggest that you might consider applying to the smaller ones first.Straight out of uni you'll find that your CV, cover notes & interview technique could do with the polish that these initial applications provide.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: How good is good?
 
Ned
15.07.8 00:00
 
It sounds like you have the credentials to miss the automatic first stage C.V. cull. However, if there is nothing magnificent that makes you stand out, there is a real risk that, after a closer inspection, MBBB will be too bored by your application to take it very seriously. MBBB are used to ridiculously talented candidates. Being averagely brilliant means that you just have to absolutely nail all the bits that banking interns (with a PHd in nuclear physics and who've founded their own e-business etc) might be a bit blase about. For example - the covering letter - dont just ham out the usual "i like consulting because of the range of skills it develops and the diverse industries I will be exposed to etc etc..." This is the sort of pre-packaged boll*cks that 90% of candidates will espouse and 95% of them will get canned. Be origina, take a few risks, over-emphasise your extracurriculars, and most importantly of all be supremely confident. MBBB want intellectual leaders, you have to assume your good enough to apply - its an exclusive club, and you have to think you are more than good enough to get in. Also, this is getting ahead of yourself a bit, but if you get an interview, become a case-study machine. Literally hours of these every day or you will not stand a chance. Ned
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: How good is good?
 
Original Poster
16.07.8 00:00
 
Thank you,very encouraging,
 
Reply

Reply

 
Return to the top of page.

ThreadID: 0