Search:
search button
Final round: brick wall?
 
13 posts
30.01.8
OC&C vs. Bain
 
3 posts
26.01.8
How are things at EY BAS
 
19 posts
30.01.8
Freshminds - stepping stone to consulting?
 
9 posts
28.01.8
working hours?
 
19 posts
26.01.8
OC&C Starting Salary?
 
12 posts
25.01.8
The tribute to Sir John
 
1 posts
24.01.8
LECG and NERA - what's the scoop?
 
3 posts
28.01.8
Consultancy Placement
 
1 posts
23.01.8
Idling on client site
 
2 posts
23.01.8
PA Consulting - Salary Bands...
 
22 posts
01.08.8
Stress
 
7 posts
24.01.8
HR Re-Apply Policy...12months or Next Application Year?
 
2 posts
24.01.8
What exactly is Enterprise Resource Planning...
 
16 posts
25.01.8
Consulting opportunities in Middle East/Gulf?
 
23 posts
20.02.8
OC&C vs. EY BAS
 
11 posts
24.01.8
Strategy analysts - getting sacked
 
7 posts
24.01.8
A career in IB
 
3 posts
22.01.8
Why is consulting a "Tough nut to crack"?
 
6 posts
09.02.8
most absurd guesstimate
 
16 posts
24.01.8
Cap Gemini salaries
 
1 posts
22.01.8
Market jitters - cause for concern?
 
6 posts
24.01.8
Dilema - Big 4 or small consultancy firm?
 
4 posts
24.01.8
When to re-apply?
 
3 posts
23.01.8
Manager / M1 Salary at Accenture
 
4 posts
25.01.8
Salaries at PWC
 
9 posts
22.01.8
LEK final round tomorrow - any info please
 
3 posts
09.02.8
interview with VP
 
1 posts
21.01.8
lie on cv
 
6 posts
21.01.8
EY Programme Advisory Services Vs Investment Banking ASAP
 
4 posts
14.02.8
Aston Carter International
 
4 posts
27.01.8
Roland Berger
 
6 posts
21.01.8
Bain -- written case study
 
8 posts
27.08.10
A degree in Sociology?
 
19 posts
22.01.8
interview prep
 
4 posts
19.01.8
Sold myself short..?
 
4 posts
20.01.8
Career ladder at PwC
 
1 posts
19.01.8
Friday for Consultants
 
12 posts
18.01.8
ACN: management consulting v analyst consulting
 
3 posts
18.01.8
EY PAS to Investment Banking
 
1 posts
18.01.8
Rambo and Rocky
 
8 posts
17.01.8
How does consulting measure up?
 
9 posts
03.02.8
Spellathon
 
5 posts
18.01.8
Deloitte Consulting Unraveled...
 
8 posts
20.01.8
Accenture Consulting Info Reqd
 
5 posts
19.01.8
Bizaps
 
1 posts
16.01.8
L.E.K.ers. Help!
 
1 posts
16.01.8
Shirts! Jermyn Street!
 
7 posts
30.01.8
"Bless you" etiquette.
 
5 posts
31.07.18
Undergrad in his last year!
 
12 posts
22.01.8
 

Sold myself short..?

 
forum comment
#0 Sold myself short..?
 
AJ
19.01.8 00:00
 
Hi,I posted on here I while ago to help with advice and found it really helpful.I recently finished my PhD and decided not to follow academia and go for consulting instead. My PhD was quite technical, but completely academic and so there was no was to start consulting but at grad level.After a few offers and rejections I started at a Big-4 consulting arm in September and have enjoyed it thus far.Problem: I keep getting people at the firm and otherwise saying 'You've got a PhD, what are you doing here'. It's really depressing to explain to them that the PhD doesn't qualify me for anything but academia.Now I am starting to question it myself. What are my options? I'm happy where I am, but now I'm starting to wonder if I could do more.....
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: Sold myself short..?
 
AJ
19.01.8 00:00
 
(apologies for typos)
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: Sold myself short..?
 
me too
19.01.8 00:00
 
I'm in a similar situation. However, I don't have a PhD, but a "good" masters.I'm not a tier 1 or 2 candidate. It can be quite depressing.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: RE: Sold myself short..?
 
you' better think...
20.01.8 00:00
 
Firstly, unless your PHD takes straight into a relevant job (research/academia etc) it is only going to make you a person with a very well tested brain but little professional experience. ie, it is not going to a lot for you in the short term. In the longer term, however, when you get more senior, you will suddenly find that you are wanted on the key projects because you can be positioned as someone with X, Y and Z experience + a PHD. PHD + nothing = not a lot. PHD + 3-5 years of consulting experience = a hell of a lot.As far as the comments go, has it occured to you that your colleagues might be threatened by you? They do not want Mr or Mrs PHD floating around, making them look bad. If you in a large and respected player as you seem to be, you can be assured that the company can cope with you. You may have some frustrations early on but stick with it, I say. If you do not, you may end up having one of those CV's, which cries out "bright academic who could not cut it in the real world". Seriously though, if you are with a good company and do well, you will be fine and will progress. Those who mock you are just threatened.
 
Reply

Reply

 
Return to the top of page.

ThreadID: 0