Search:
search button
Final round: brick wall?
 
13 posts
30.01.8
OC&C vs. Bain
 
3 posts
26.01.8
How are things at EY BAS
 
19 posts
30.01.8
Freshminds - stepping stone to consulting?
 
9 posts
28.01.8
working hours?
 
19 posts
26.01.8
OC&C Starting Salary?
 
12 posts
25.01.8
The tribute to Sir John
 
1 posts
24.01.8
LECG and NERA - what's the scoop?
 
3 posts
28.01.8
Consultancy Placement
 
1 posts
23.01.8
Idling on client site
 
2 posts
23.01.8
PA Consulting - Salary Bands...
 
22 posts
01.08.8
Stress
 
7 posts
24.01.8
HR Re-Apply Policy...12months or Next Application Year?
 
2 posts
24.01.8
What exactly is Enterprise Resource Planning...
 
16 posts
25.01.8
Consulting opportunities in Middle East/Gulf?
 
23 posts
20.02.8
OC&C vs. EY BAS
 
11 posts
24.01.8
Strategy analysts - getting sacked
 
7 posts
24.01.8
A career in IB
 
3 posts
22.01.8
Why is consulting a "Tough nut to crack"?
 
6 posts
09.02.8
most absurd guesstimate
 
16 posts
24.01.8
Cap Gemini salaries
 
1 posts
22.01.8
Market jitters - cause for concern?
 
6 posts
24.01.8
Dilema - Big 4 or small consultancy firm?
 
4 posts
24.01.8
When to re-apply?
 
3 posts
23.01.8
Manager / M1 Salary at Accenture
 
4 posts
25.01.8
Salaries at PWC
 
9 posts
22.01.8
LEK final round tomorrow - any info please
 
3 posts
09.02.8
interview with VP
 
1 posts
21.01.8
lie on cv
 
6 posts
21.01.8
EY Programme Advisory Services Vs Investment Banking ASAP
 
4 posts
14.02.8
Aston Carter International
 
4 posts
27.01.8
Roland Berger
 
6 posts
21.01.8
Bain -- written case study
 
8 posts
27.08.10
A degree in Sociology?
 
19 posts
22.01.8
interview prep
 
4 posts
19.01.8
Sold myself short..?
 
4 posts
20.01.8
Career ladder at PwC
 
1 posts
19.01.8
Friday for Consultants
 
12 posts
18.01.8
ACN: management consulting v analyst consulting
 
3 posts
18.01.8
EY PAS to Investment Banking
 
1 posts
18.01.8
Rambo and Rocky
 
8 posts
17.01.8
How does consulting measure up?
 
9 posts
03.02.8
Spellathon
 
5 posts
18.01.8
Deloitte Consulting Unraveled...
 
8 posts
20.01.8
Accenture Consulting Info Reqd
 
5 posts
19.01.8
Bizaps
 
1 posts
16.01.8
L.E.K.ers. Help!
 
1 posts
16.01.8
Shirts! Jermyn Street!
 
7 posts
30.01.8
"Bless you" etiquette.
 
5 posts
31.07.18
Undergrad in his last year!
 
12 posts
22.01.8
 

most absurd guesstimate

 
forum comment
#0 most absurd guesstimate
 
consultant
22.01.8 00:00
 
guesstimates are besides other things intended to catch you by surprise and to throw you off - so what's the craziest guesstimate you ever heard or you could ever think of?Ill start - not extremely spectacular, but still: How much does New York weigh?
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: most absurd guesstimate
 
NEWYORKNEWYORK
22.01.8 00:00
 
The state or the city?
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: most absurd guesstimate
 
consultant
22.01.8 00:00
 
they were talking of the city (actually got that one a while ago)just curious what others have heard or can come up with
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: RE: most absurd guesstimate
 
anon
22.01.8 00:00
 
How many baked beans fit inside a VW Beetle?
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: RE: RE: most absurd guesstimate
 
ginster
22.01.8 00:00
 
How many roads must a man walk down before you can call him a man.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: most absurd guesstimate
 
anon
23.01.8 00:00
 
How long is a piece of string?
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: most absurd guesstimate
 
Corporate Whore
23.01.8 00:00
 
How long is a piece of string?"Twice the size of half it's length" - My mate 'Dave'http://corporatewhore.blog.com
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: RE: most absurd guesstimate
 
?
23.01.8 00:00
 
How much does New York weigh? What answer did you give?
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: RE: RE: most absurd guesstimate
 
TB
23.01.8 00:00
 
THe question about NY is amazing.. Answering would be very difficult, but I think a good way to tackle this problem is start asking for sensible info..For example:1. Do I have to consider also people and cars in NY? Or can I just consider buildings?2. Is night or day? (During the day obviously there are more people than night in NY)After this intro, we need to ask the interviewer lots of thing. We need some info to start a decent reasoning. If the interviewer doesn't provide any useful info concerning avg building weight or volume, then we need to make assumptions.I think the key is just to be creative. One important thing that I will mention is the fact there is Central Park which must be taken into account during our process.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: most absurd guesstimate
 
The Senior Vice President
23.01.8 00:00
 
I once asked the following question:How much horsepower does it take to run the Internet?Hehe.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: most absurd guesstimate
 
consultant
23.01.8 00:00
 
I tackled the one about NY roughly the following:How many inhabitants + workers/tourists and their avg. weightNo. of cars and their weightWith the buildings it gets really tricky. Obviously I had no idea what a house weighs, so I said a family house should equal to about 60 cars of 1.5 t, so around 90,000t per house. The funny thing: a few weeks later I found that a family house on avg weighs around 100,000t so I wasnt even too far off. But it gets even worse when you try to consider all the skyscrapers and also the underground. At Senior Vice President: you didnt really want to give that applicant a chance did you :-)
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: most absurd guesstimate
 
student
23.01.8 00:00
 
I know these are supposeed to test your thought processes and logic, but how are you supposed to answer these? How much are you allowed to assume?If I assumed that the average house weighed 10t and the average skyscraper 100,000t would I be marked down considering that these figures are way off?Am I expected to know about Central Park and that? I'm good at creative, but my knowledge in this area would have been poor.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: most absurd guesstimate
 
TB
23.01.8 00:00
 
Everyone knows that there is Central Park in NY.. Remember, if you don't know anything about the subject, state it clearly to your interviewer. This is way better than assuming things when you have zero knowledge.Summing up, my approach is:1. Asking for precise information2. If the interviewer gives me the info I need, then I'm fine3. If the interviewer wants me to make assumptions, I will make them relying on my knowledge4. If I don't know anything, before starting with assumptions I will say to the interviewer "Since I don't know anything about this topic, would you explain me sth?"
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: most absurd guesstimate
 
consultant
23.01.8 00:00
 
whenever I had such guesstimates I was never provided with any further information. Obviously you have to deal with numbers here you absolutely dont know. So as TB said, I always stated where I was missing any info and how I would approximate it. I guess thats the only way you can really do it since there are too many things you just dont know in this case.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: most absurd guesstimate
 
caerurfan
24.01.8 00:00
 
..the answer my friend is blowing in the wind...
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 How much does new york weigh?
 
caerurfan
24.01.8 00:00
 
How much does New York weigh?. Answer: Don't know for sure but if it is typical of the USA then it'll be about 30% heavier than it should be..
 
Reply

Reply

 
Return to the top of page.

ThreadID: 0