Search:
search button
BP situation
 
18 posts
28.06.10
The grass is NOT greener
 
10 posts
16.06.10
Accenture outsourcing
 
11 posts
15.11.10
Consulting my way out of here
 
5 posts
16.06.10
Project Management Consultancies
 
8 posts
21.06.10
Accenture Mobile Phone policy
 
10 posts
17.06.10
Hackett Group / PWC / IBM / Deloitte for finance transformation?
 
4 posts
16.06.10
Business Design
 
2 posts
14.06.10
Tell George Osbore what you think he can cut
 
1 posts
13.06.10
Did PA or EDS ever pay for the data losses?
 
33 posts
12.11.10
Politics in consulting
 
4 posts
15.06.10
accenture advice
 
5 posts
13.06.10
case study practice partner
 
2 posts
10.06.10
Heels in the City
 
2 posts
10.06.10
Funny nicknames for consultants
 
17 posts
18.06.10
house: to buy or not to buy?
 
10 posts
14.06.10
house: to buy or not to buy?
 
4 posts
14.06.10
Excel VBA - do I need it?
 
5 posts
15.06.10
Accenture
 
7 posts
11.06.10
What is the pay banding for a people & change senior consultant at EY UK
 
6 posts
10.06.10
Case Study interview preparation
 
1 posts
09.06.10
Working at Simon Kucher & Partners
 
4 posts
07.07.10
career change
 
2 posts
09.06.10
IBM Offer
 
11 posts
10.06.10
Consulting in non-profit orgnizations
 
4 posts
01.07.10
Siemens BBC contract
 
1 posts
09.06.10
Help with difficult client
 
7 posts
12.06.10
Prince2 - do I need it?
 
10 posts
15.06.10
Opportunities @ Booz
 
5 posts
08.06.10
Deloitte TI Assessment Centre Phase
 
3 posts
16.06.10
Which job is safer?
 
3 posts
08.06.10
What is the value of generalist
 
6 posts
07.06.10
PhD with exp - BCG 1st round
 
1 posts
05.06.10
Where to live in London
 
49 posts
05.02.13
Programme Advisory Services
 
1 posts
04.06.10
Equivalent Contract rates
 
7 posts
06.06.10
Accenture no response after 2nd round
 
4 posts
05.06.13
LOC Consulting
 
2 posts
04.06.10
IBM salaries at PRG 7 and 8
 
1 posts
03.06.10
Deloitte associate partner
 
14 posts
20.06.10
what's the next merketing label?
 
12 posts
03.06.10
Merger Booz/A.T. Kearney - ftd reports
 
8 posts
04.06.10
Telling recruiters about other interviews
 
7 posts
04.06.10
Driving licence in IBM
 
2 posts
01.06.10
Question for MBA grads
 
4 posts
03.06.10
Dream job
 
3 posts
02.06.10
Transitioning to Contracting - Notice Period
 
5 posts
06.06.10
Business Ethics in International Consultancy
 
2 posts
31.05.10
Qualifications on CV
 
8 posts
15.09.10
Deloitte Ops vs KPMG Ops Strat vs OW
 
3 posts
17.08.10
 

Telling recruiters about other interviews

 
forum comment
#0 Telling recruiters about other interviews
 
SH
01.06.10 00:00
 
Many times when I have a 1st or 2nd round interview most recruiters ask where I am interviewing and at what stage I am with other companies and to let them know if I reach final stage. This is understandable.But from my point of view, should I be honest? Say I had a 2nd round interview with one company and they want to progress to final round but I would also be having 2nd round with another company which is my first preference over the one where I am in final round.Do you guys honestly tell recruiters where you are with other companies especially if the other companies are your first preference but you are still few rounds away from getting an offer ?Lying would get you in bad books of the recruiters (which is ok) but also the company where you went through three rounds ?
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: Telling recruiters about other interviews
 
sm
01.06.10 00:00
 
Found myself in this situation a few months back. I explained to the 2nd recruiter I was at final interview but I preferred to keep confidential the name of the company. He understood the situation, then once I had the offer in writing, told him who it was. Result - happy candidate, good experience with the 2nd recruiter, would use him next time.I can imagine there are lots of cowboys out there though but a good one will understand your position. If it gets you in their bad books its probably because they want to put their own candidate into the company and deprive you of a job
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: Telling recruiters about other interviews
 
Mars A Day
02.06.10 00:00
 
Telling your recruiter is not only the professional and considerate thing to do (they are after all putting in a lot of work on your behalf) but the information can also be useful - they can advise their client that you are interviewing at x stage elsewhere, which may hurry their own client along, it provides a degree of assurance to their client that you are in demand, and they can also then advise their client on how best to sell themselves to you (it's a two way process after all).
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: Telling recruiters about other interviews
 
recruiter too
02.06.10 00:00
 
Well yes but in case we all get a bit too cosy here…While all of the above IS true it is also true that many recruiters will ask so that they can either cold call the client and try and put in other candidates (ie and possibly knock you out) or worse they might actually have their own candidates up for the role and it would therefore be in their interest to ensure you DON’T get the job.Also there are of course occasions when the recruitment is confidential.If you trust the recruiter and know them then fine (and clearly to NOT tell them does imply to them that you don’t which isn’t ideal for the relationship) but otherwise be careful
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: Telling recruiters about other interviews
 
Craig Milbourne
02.06.10 00:00
 
If you are honest then it gives me a good idea of what forms will be interested in you and it gives me great leverage (social proof) to be able to say in all honesty that you passed a 1st or 2nd round with a credible cponsultancy. It also shows your focus.And for example if your interviewing at 2nd round with Deloitte, its hardly news that they are hiring and to contact them with candidates specultaively a) you can lose ownership if you have no mandate b) it will just annoy them as they have a PSL c) Id probably not get a response.Whats better for me a recruiter is to understand why the other company is your preferred choice so that I can provide you with roles or advice according to your drivers and motivators and help you evaluate my role too.I'd gain insignificant advantage in my job by you telling me that 3 or 4 branded company names are hiring. I know this already as they have adverts up all over Top Consultant and the internet and its a "under cover" role is probably retained anyway and paid for so it would be pointless. They'll be on my propsect list anyway so if it was that simple I'd already be working with them.It can take 6 months or a year to win an account so start legitimately sending in CV's and with the big players its all tied down on fixed term contracts that have a tendering process.In summary - you dont have much to worry about.Craig.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: RE: Telling recruiters about other interviews
 
Anon
03.06.10 00:00
 
CraigI enjoyed reading your other post in the early hours before it mysteriously disappeared....actually didn't think it was too controversial but apparently I am in the minority
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: RE: RE: Telling recruiters about other interviews
 
Another Anon
04.06.10 00:00
 
Bump for Anon above
 
Reply

Reply

 
Return to the top of page.

ThreadID: 0