Search:
search button
Shell
 
14 posts
26.11.8
Control Risks
 
3 posts
01.12.8
I want in Accenture!
 
17 posts
26.11.8
Income Protection Insurance
 
4 posts
19.11.8
Awesome position or awesome company
 
7 posts
20.11.8
Marakon Associate
 
5 posts
19.11.8
Background checks by Big Four
 
11 posts
20.11.8
Mercer Oliver Wyman
 
10 posts
18.01.9
Bearingpoint Info
 
5 posts
19.11.8
Oliver Wyman tests
 
3 posts
20.11.8
Brand vs Experience
 
6 posts
21.11.8
Deloitte laying people off!
 
4 posts
20.11.8
Convince me to join consulting
 
10 posts
21.11.8
Impact of crisis on strat consulting firms
 
7 posts
18.11.8
Jokes - Anyone got any good ones???
 
9 posts
22.11.8
Application Dilemma
 
15 posts
18.11.8
Financial Consulting/Corporate Finance
 
2 posts
18.11.8
Deloitte Assessment Centre - Postponed to January
 
5 posts
18.11.8
Strategic Management Consultant Designation!
 
13 posts
21.12.8
BCG rejections???
 
5 posts
20.11.8
BCG & OC&C redundancies?
 
2 posts
18.11.8
job opportunity for recent graduate
 
1 posts
18.11.8
anyone heard back yet???
 
48 posts
09.12.8
Accenture vs McDonalds
 
12 posts
21.11.8
Strat firm downturn?
 
2 posts
19.11.8
Vacancy Advertising
 
8 posts
18.11.8
Fancy things... ways to impress
 
5 posts
18.11.8
EY FAS redundancies
 
2 posts
17.11.8
good time to look round?
 
6 posts
18.11.8
Big 5 after MBA
 
13 posts
25.11.8
Semi competent employee
 
16 posts
18.11.8
BTO in McKinsey and analogs
 
2 posts
16.11.8
Booz & Co Beirut
 
10 posts
01.12.8
Deloitte Technology Integration, CRM Practice
 
1 posts
16.11.8
E&Y BAS Technology Enablement
 
11 posts
07.02.9
When interviews?
 
2 posts
15.11.8
Please Help! IBM Strategy and Change
 
6 posts
17.11.8
Very, very, very.......OK?
 
4 posts
15.11.8
YES!! I GOT INTO CONSULTING!
 
16 posts
21.03.9
Perception on Business and Information Strategy in Cap
 
4 posts
14.11.8
Technology Enablement in EY
 
5 posts
16.11.8
ATOS Assessment Centre
 
1 posts
13.11.8
Interview Expenses
 
7 posts
24.11.8
Good Consultancy company profile sources
 
6 posts
18.11.8
Career in IT / IT Consultancy worthwhile
 
1 posts
13.11.8
Only fools join consulting at entry level
 
59 posts
17.11.8
Name collectors
 
9 posts
12.11.8
Career move to Consulting...
 
6 posts
13.11.8
Which firm has the strongest reputation in Russia?
 
1 posts
12.11.8
(In Russia) Which firm has the strongest reputation?
 
2 posts
12.11.8
 

Brand vs Experience

 
forum comment
#0 Brand vs Experience
 
confused
19.11.8 00:00
 
How important is a good company brand compared to a good job experience when you can only have 1 and not both.For example, lets say you had two choices:- work at a well known company, but doing really entry level work (mbbb, big4, etc where you are basically doing powerpoint/excel/admin work)- work at an unknown smaller company, but doing higher level work (having a strong input and role into the company's strategic planning)I ask this because I currently have a few offers. I have an offer to work at a well known consultancy where the job experience isn't that great and i have an offer to work at a small unknown company where i get more say and can really help in the company's strategic planning (not just a cog in a big wheel).So ultimately what should I choose? Should I take the job with the better brand or the job with the better experience? What looks better on your CV doing not so great work at a great well known company or doing really great work at a relatively unknown company.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: Brand vs Experience
 
Tired of reading same post after same post
19.11.8 00:00
 
Yawn.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: Brand vs Experience
 
Me
19.11.8 00:00
 
My view-Take the job with the brand, spend two years doing the "boring" stuff and then move onto the interesting stuff after.A lot of the "boring stuff" you talk about involves acquiring skills that people will value and you will need later on. Sounds like you are a recent grad. Despite what you may have been sold, you are unlikely to be having a strong input into the companys strategic planning. Don't run before you can walk.The other issue, particularly in the current climate, is risk - what happens to you when your small unknown company goes bankrupt in 6 months time??
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: Brand vs Experience
 
td
19.11.8 00:00
 
striong inputs, gain valuable expereince, not some script kidie shits so when u do crack into a decent position with a nice comp you'll have da experience to make it
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: RE: Brand vs Experience
 
...
19.11.8 00:00
 
I work for a small strat company. I've been given a lot of responsibility and autonomy and have gained a lot of experience in a short period of time. I will be able to rise through the ranks a lot quicker but the pay isn't quite as good right now so everything is a trade off.Personally, although I like my job and appreciate the experience I'm gaining, I'd probably put the hard time in at the top firm early on. P.s. I have active input into strategy development, presenting, project managing etc., but ppt and excel are the tools of our trade - you're not getting away from them for a long time
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: Brand vs Experience
 
I like pamela
21.11.8 00:00
 
If you are a recent graduate, then go for the brand. If you have decent experience, then go for the smaller company. They will likely treat you better and give you better job duties.If you are looking to get laid, then also go for the brand.
 
Reply

Reply

 
Return to the top of page.

ThreadID: 0