How does the package at the boutique compare vs the offer at EY? Is the difference really 25% when all is considered? If it is, then why would you take EY’s offer unless you think that the big 4 experience will be an investment that will ultimately pay off. I was in a similar position to you 6 months ago. I had an offer from one of the big 4 and one from boutique consultancy. The starting offer was some 20% below that of the boutique but the boutique didn’t offer a pension scheme, private healthcare, bonus etc. This closed the gap to around 5%, I then negotiated with the big 4 and accepted an offer with them. The final basic salary was only £2k lower than the boutique.