Search:
search button
Best route into consulting
 
3 posts
06.04.7
Detica 2nd round
 
5 posts
11.04.7
Where to go after 2 years?
 
7 posts
07.04.7
PLM@Atos
 
1 posts
05.04.7
Best PE departments?
 
3 posts
05.04.7
Consulting in Australia? Thinking about making the move!
 
8 posts
11.04.7
PIC Assessment centre
 
5 posts
26.05.7
Consulting Scotland
 
1 posts
05.04.7
PA 'ISI' Practice
 
2 posts
05.04.7
Try again or get some experience first?
 
1 posts
05.04.7
Accenture
 
2 posts
06.04.7
Winning work
 
16 posts
10.04.7
Strategy without MBA ?
 
4 posts
05.04.7
Adventures in Consultant Land
 
3 posts
05.04.7
What are my chances???
 
6 posts
12.04.7
I can't break it!
 
4 posts
05.04.7
Job search
 
2 posts
03.04.7
How to change jobs
 
3 posts
03.04.7
Japanese PhD graduate looking to pursue career in consulting
 
4 posts
03.04.7
grad job to grad job?
 
2 posts
03.04.7
Info, pls.
 
2 posts
03.04.7
Syncron
 
1 posts
03.04.7
Postgraduate Studies - is it worth?
 
3 posts
05.04.7
Body Language
 
3 posts
03.04.7
Simple interview question
 
5 posts
04.04.7
Port Jackson Partners
 
3 posts
03.04.7
Questions
 
15 posts
07.04.7
Consulting companies
 
1 posts
30.03.7
What is your worst interview experience
 
3 posts
30.03.7
PA career progression
 
3 posts
30.03.7
Decisions: my options
 
3 posts
30.03.7
An honest opinion about consulting!
 
8 posts
08.06.7
Booz Allen - Senior Consultant vs Associate
 
20 posts
03.04.7
'Speculate to Accumulate'
 
3 posts
29.03.7
Hobbies
 
5 posts
29.03.7
Let's Huddle!
 
3 posts
29.03.7
SCHLUMBERGER Business Consulting - Any
 
5 posts
03.04.7
Smoking - is it cool or not?
 
18 posts
24.07.7
Best city/country to live
 
23 posts
11.04.7
Move into Consultancy? Your thoughts.
 
20 posts
10.05.7
Capgemini ATP Assessment Centre
 
1 posts
29.03.7
Calling all experienced consultants
 
7 posts
04.04.7
Being interviewed for UK (C&HT) group
 
3 posts
30.09.7
Deloitte S&O consultant offer! Advice needed
 
1 posts
28.03.7
Should I stay or I should I go now??
 
5 posts
28.03.7
PwC PIC V Accenture Business Consulting
 
2 posts
28.03.7
Do they pay more in Deloitte strategy??
 
3 posts
29.03.7
PA 'on-boarding week'
 
5 posts
29.03.7
Consultant Strategy & Ops Offer Deloitte Perth Australia
 
1 posts
27.03.7
HR Consulting: PhD graduate
 
4 posts
27.03.7
 

Simple interview question

 
forum comment
#0 Simple interview question
 
Simple
02.04.7 00:00
 
Here's a simple interview question that I've had a couple of times:"Why do people need consultants?"I'd be very interested to hear peoples answers.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: Simple interview question
 
anon
02.04.7 00:00
 
well in a nut shell, they're needed to help companies improve performance through analysis of existing business problems and development of future plans
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: Simple interview question
 
detere
02.04.7 00:00
 
Some, or all of the following reasons:* Because executives can't see the wood for the trees* Because executives don't know who they have in the organisation who could do the job, can't find them, or don't trust them, whereas consultants proactively promote their capabilities to clients with websites, glossy brochures, and produce detailed proposals and flashy resumes each time they pitch for work* Because consultants are always available, work to unrealistic deadlines, accomodate changes of scope without complaining (not to the client's face at least) and are more flexible than the resources executives have in-house* Because having consultants around makes executives feel more important and clever* Because executives don't like to make unpopular decisions without external support, or want visible validation that their decisions have been "independently" verified* Because consultancies contain talents that are difficult for clients to aggregate in one place themselves and which they could not economically justify employing as they do not generate the critical mass of work to keep those staff fully deployed (and interested)* Because using consultants keeps headcount off the books, they can be hired and fired at will with few legal challenges, they can be used for short-term projects but unlike most temps they're motivated and prepared to work hard, and come back for more no matter how badly you treat them* Because consultants sometimes work out cheaper on an hourly or piecework basis than permanent staff* Because executives want to cultivate networks with those consultancies they intend to join themselves in a few years timeI have used the term "executives" to refer to consulting buyers, but you can also read it as "senior civil servants".
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: Simple interview question
 
anon
02.04.7 00:00
 
Analysis and planning are true at the junior end of the spectrum in terms of what consultants themselves do.In terms of why consultants do this, from a customer perspective, clients want consultants for their opinions and ability to back those opinions up with knowledge and insight (which is where the research, analysis and planning comes in). Half the consultant's skill is in working out what opinion to have.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: Simple interview question
 
Tony Restell
04.04.7 00:00
 
"Why do people need consultants?" 100% agree with detere's reasons, all very valid. Ultimately these reasons can all be summed up by saying that "organisations use consultants to solve a business or managerial problem that can be better solved by bringing in external experts than turning to existing in-house resources".The flip side of this, for interview purposes, is that to be a good consultant you therefore have to bring to the client some expertise or capacity to get things done that is not already available within the client's business.Good luck with those interviewsRgds, Tony RestellTop-Consultant.com
 
Reply

Reply

 
Return to the top of page.

ThreadID: 0