Search:
search button
MC after traineeship
 
6 posts
13.10.6
Is CapGem That Bad?
 
4 posts
20.10.6
Preparing for consulting.
 
2 posts
09.10.6
Career change
 
3 posts
09.10.6
Deloitte Technology Assurance and Advisory Question
 
3 posts
09.10.6
Axon final interview
 
4 posts
10.10.6
Deloitte- Manager in TI
 
6 posts
29.10.6
Accenture SITE practice
 
4 posts
31.01.7
PWC Strategy Group
 
2 posts
07.10.6
Consulting Firms
 
1 posts
07.10.6
how many steps will a msc climb?
 
3 posts
06.10.6
Job Swap
 
3 posts
08.10.6
who are the hackett group?
 
3 posts
07.10.6
SAP Business Consulting
 
4 posts
08.10.6
BPI and InfoSec instructor
 
1 posts
05.10.6
Career Advancement V Industry experience
 
1 posts
05.10.6
Internal Learning at Big 4
 
10 posts
14.10.6
Relocating to the UK
 
3 posts
05.10.6
Best Skills to Equip for ACN
 
3 posts
06.10.6
Beng - send your CV over.
 
13 posts
17.10.6
EY BAS - How's it going?
 
9 posts
13.10.6
Are exploding offers common?
 
12 posts
08.10.6
how consultants are seen by the world
 
7 posts
07.10.6
Post-Accenture careers
 
16 posts
30.10.6
Boxwood Consultants
 
1 posts
05.10.6
E&Y Technical Interview
 
4 posts
06.10.6
How long to spend in consulting before returning to industry?
 
3 posts
04.10.6
Back Office Associates
 
1 posts
04.10.6
Agencies and Search Engines appropriate for PhDs with no Experience
 
5 posts
04.10.6
BDO Stoy Hayward Management Consulting Arm?
 
1 posts
04.10.6
Deloitte: Trying to understand - Beng?
 
1 posts
04.10.6
Beng & others please advise
 
3 posts
04.10.6
OC&C Strategy Consultants
 
20 posts
18.01.7
EU working hours?
 
2 posts
04.10.6
Bestoftimes/Worstoftimes
 
3 posts
05.10.6
On Emmigration
 
2 posts
05.10.6
case: framework vs. hypothesis
 
4 posts
03.10.6
Consulting world and career
 
1 posts
03.10.6
An average day within strategy consulting
 
15 posts
06.10.6
Box ticking
 
1 posts
03.10.6
Legal Notice
 
1 posts
03.10.6
Spectrum
 
1 posts
03.10.6
Transport specialists
 
9 posts
18.10.6
IBM vs boutique strat firm?
 
9 posts
04.10.6
PA or PwC for Government consulting?
 
4 posts
05.10.6
Deloitte Bonus
 
3 posts
04.10.6
Good enough for consulting
 
5 posts
04.10.6
IBM Financial management consultant
 
5 posts
04.10.6
Deloitte vs Mckinsey
 
1 posts
02.10.6
What is tier 1? becuase it isnt work
 
15 posts
01.05.8
 

Deloitte vs Mckinsey

 
forum comment
#0 Deloitte vs Mckinsey
 
Craig
02.10.6 00:00
 
Hi, I know what the immediate responses are going to be: ' no deloitte strat is a tier 2, tier 1 is only Mck, Bain, BCG etc etc'I want to probe further. I think what we define here as tier 1 / 2 etc oftentimes is a defenition of the BRAND - not of the type of work or client base.Of course i agree that Mckinsey has outstanding people and delivers superb work. However - is it greatly superior to that of a Deloitte of a Roland Berger? Dont they deliver the same work for same clients just calling it differently?Take BP for example: at any given point in time there are several of the top consultancies in thier london offices. Accenture is there, Booz is there, Deloitte and Mckinsey.But if you look closely, McKinsey's 'growth strategy' is a very similar to Deloitte's 'fundamental business review' - which in turn is similar to Booz's revenue analysis etc etc. So my question to you: are the tiers that we so often obsess about created by success and innovation of delivery or are they solely about prestige and brand. ( and thus higher fees)??
 
Reply

Reply

 
Return to the top of page.

ThreadID: 0