Search:
search button
How will the consulting industry evolve?
 
1 posts
10.02.16
Right time to move to consulting?
 
13 posts
17.02.16
MBB - Associate/Consultant Lateral Hire - Negotiating Salary
 
3 posts
10.02.16
PwC Final Interview - Consulting
 
1 posts
09.02.16
How does one answer this?
 
8 posts
12.02.16
Final Partner "Fit" Interview
 
3 posts
09.02.16
Town named after me
 
13 posts
25.02.16
PwC Consultant moving to Europe
 
2 posts
08.02.16
Level 6 at Deloitte
 
1 posts
06.02.16
Offer Timing after Final Round (Off-Cycle)
 
7 posts
15.02.16
MBB Culture & Work/Life Balance in SE Asia
 
7 posts
08.02.16
Delivering a superior presentation
 
3 posts
04.02.16
Consultancies like PRTM (R&D / Product Innovation)
 
2 posts
08.02.16
PA Consulting vs. Big 4 (KPMG)
 
1 posts
03.02.16
Where to find boutique firm listings to cold email for summer internships
 
1 posts
03.02.16
Consulting firm criminal background check?
 
4 posts
03.02.16
McKinsey Solutions
 
1 posts
02.02.16
A New Beginning...
 
18 posts
04.02.16
What does "More Structured" mean?
 
7 posts
02.02.16
Leveraging MBB Invitation to hedge my bets?
 
1 posts
27.01.16
Looking for work in and around Brussels/Antwerp
 
3 posts
28.01.16
BE, MBA - Struggling to get interviews/Jobs - 7 Yrs exp. Ex Accenture
 
23 posts
11.02.16
PWC Delivering Deal Value Team Interview
 
1 posts
26.01.16
IT Salary Advice
 
24 posts
24.02.16
How to deal with very difficult manager where relationship is becoming Personal?
 
5 posts
25.01.16
What is "superior" financial modeling?
 
11 posts
04.02.16
Which firms to look at for human capital consulting
 
5 posts
19.02.16
PA Consulting or ARM?
 
12 posts
04.02.16
London Commute Negotiation
 
12 posts
01.03.16
financial consultant at ibm
 
36 posts
17.02.16
Internal Mobility @ KPMG
 
2 posts
21.01.16
IBM GBS - APAC Salary Bands
 
1 posts
19.01.16
In the recruitment process, then all of a sudden....I'm not (I think)
 
3 posts
19.01.16
investment banking levels vs consulting
 
7 posts
15.02.16
Accenture - Experienced International Hire
 
1 posts
18.01.16
Case Interview Prep Buddy
 
3 posts
18.01.16
Advice on job search
 
2 posts
13.01.16
PwC Induction Experienced Hire (Consulting)
 
3 posts
14.01.16
Have I missed my chance for 2016?
 
3 posts
15.02.16
Offer Letter Delay at Deloitte
 
11 posts
19.12.18
Salary expectation for consultant level in Deloitte
 
4 posts
07.01.16
PwC Assesment centre and Salary for Manager
 
5 posts
09.03.16
What are the best consulting companies to work for? Why?
 
10 posts
02.03.16
Hello! What tools would you want in an online consulting work-space for consultants and their clients?
 
3 posts
02.01.16
Accenture Level 12 Salary expectations
 
2 posts
31.12.15
Negotiate Entry Level Consulting offer
 
1 posts
29.12.15
MBA at 36?
 
8 posts
04.01.16
Tech to Consulting and Back
 
4 posts
29.12.15
What does it takes to start into management consulting?
 
5 posts
21.01.16
3 Yrs Big 4 - need a change
 
3 posts
05.01.16
 

What is "superior" financial modeling?

 
forum comment
#0 What is "superior" financial modeling?
 
Dan! Dan! Dan!
23.01.16 00:00
 
I'm writing a job description for my team (manager, corporate strategy - FMCG). I have taken the last version that was posted a couple of years ago as a starting point, and as expected, we were looking for a world-leading polymath: excellent interpersonal, superior financial modeling, top class problem solving, thought leader, 150+ years experience, 200+ languages, mba, etc...I am trying to do something apparently revolutionary and actually describe the role and person we realistically think will be happy to do it for the money on offer.The first issue I am encountering is cutting through the nebulous term financial modeling (FM). Every job wants "superior" FM skills these days, but FM presumably takes in a broad continuum of knowledge.Is there a general understanding out there around what is meant by superior FM in a strategy context? Are we talking massive LBO models, with scrnarios, capital efficiency, taxation, dilution , and other implications? I just want someone who understands the principles of financial statements, can come up with good ways to forecast performance (this, to me, is the real value add - we'll presumably have AI doing the rest soon) build a clean DCF in excel, and know when to google/ask for help. What do you call that?
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: What is "superior" financial modeling?
 
Mr Cool
24.01.16 00:00
 
Why not simply follow your own advice; tidy up what you just written into a few bullet points and put that in the JD and job ad. Then spend more time in the interview getting candidates to prove they can do these simple things and no time on trying to find out if their interpretation of nebulous labels is the same as yours.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: What is "superior" financial modeling?
 
Dan! Dan! Dan!
25.01.16 00:00
 
That's the plan. But I guess the question this raises for me a more general one. Is the concept of "financial modelling skills" just as uninformative (open to relativism, subjectivity, etc.) as something like "strong interpersonal skills", or "proficiency" in PowerPoint? Or is there a general understanding among most people in the strategy area of what is meant when someone says they have good FM skills? It's unknown to me if there is, and yet the term is almost never specified any further.The kind of modelling people do in the various areas banking, for example, is probably more predictable and standardised. Depending on the projects consultants get involved on, their FM experience can vary widely, but in my experience all of them will say they have good financial modelling skills.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: What is "superior" financial modeling?
 
Bushy Eyebrow Partner
25.01.16 00:00
 
I agree with ice-Cool Mr Cool, or "Zero-K" as I like to think of him (zero Kelvin being "absolute zero" or -273.15 degrees Celsius, which is just how cool I think he is).Words like "superior" are subjective so I'd be inclined to describe what you want - just like you've done in your post! If you feel that your description is too vague and leaves things open to interpretation, then add more detail and pin it down a bit!Now - what I need is "superior social skills". Hee hee.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: What is "superior" financial modeling?
 
marsday
25.01.16 00:00
 
'Superior' FM skills doesn't necessarily take in a broad continuum of knowledge, but it does allow the hiring manager to control and reduce the broad continuum of f**kwittedness.If said hiring manager translates the role in question into a realistic JD, with no extraneous adjectives, what happens is that you wind up with some intolerable candidate who meets the just above average metric perfectly in every way...and who one simply cannot work with. 'Lack of cultural fit' just leads to an inquisition or worse someone playing cards like discrimination. Tricky. But reject them because their above average FM modelling skills weren't quite in the 'superior' bracket...sleep easy.Actually, sleep easy anyway because it's also laziness in defining what the job actually needs.So just ask for FM skills including a proven ability to come up with good ways to forecast performance, and everything else is gravy.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: What is "superior" financial modeling?
 
Bushy Eyebrow Partner
25.01.16 00:00
 
Very cunning!!
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: What is "superior" financial modeling?
 
Camster
02.02.16 00:00
 
[quote]Why not simply follow your own advice; tidy up what you just written into a few bullet points and put that in the JD and job ad. Then spend more time in the interview getting candidates to prove they can do these simple things and no time on trying to find out if their interpretation of nebulous labels is the same as yours. [/quote]LOL! +1
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: What is "superior" financial modeling?
 
Bushy Eyebrow Partner
02.02.16 00:00
 
I'm gonna put in the next JD I write, "Must have superior social skills" hehehehehe
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: What is "superior" financial modeling?
 
Camster
02.02.16 00:00
 
The way I see it...There is a benchmark of skills that constitute FM skills.Then, there might be a step up. Let's call it advanced. At the top, there is superior.I am pretty sure that no such benchmarking exists.
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: What is "superior" financial modeling?
 
Mr Cool
03.02.16 00:00
 
[quote]I'm gonna put in the next JD I write, "Must have superior social skills" hehehehehe[/quote]I'm going to put " must have superior mah-Jong skills". Given the $hit contractors my client bank seems determined to hire, I might as well...
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: What is "superior" financial modeling?
 
Camster
04.02.16 00:00
 
I have 'superior' mahjong skills!
 
Reply

Reply

 
Return to the top of page.

ThreadID: 0