Search:
search button
My E&Y Transaction application process (So far)
 
5 posts
05.08.14
Healthcare salary consultancy- salary expectations
 
4 posts
17.11.15
KPMG Advisor interview
 
4 posts
08.07.13
Bye Bye UK
 
9 posts
13.06.13
Sigma Levels in Service Industries
 
5 posts
11.06.13
Whislteblowing
 
3 posts
10.06.13
Car Advice
 
22 posts
11.06.13
Advice for a future PhD in engineering considering management consulting
 
13 posts
11.06.15
got offered a FT job at Accenture Asia office
 
9 posts
08.06.13
Strategic Outsourcing?
 
5 posts
06.06.13
Consulting career advice sought
 
1 posts
05.06.13
Job and Education upgrade; please I need your advice seriously
 
17 posts
13.06.13
Exit option advice from Big4 MC (post MBA) to Product Management/Development
 
3 posts
07.06.13
worried!
 
6 posts
05.06.13
Lamberhurst Corporation
 
1 posts
31.05.13
Bizarre Accenture Outcome
 
19 posts
31.05.13
Dilemma
 
2 posts
30.05.13
pay on promotion
 
9 posts
07.06.13
Engagement manager (internal consulting) question
 
4 posts
30.05.13
Director IR
 
9 posts
26.06.13
Sending leaving emails
 
9 posts
30.05.13
Equity stake
 
8 posts
10.06.13
Thank you for your input
 
16 posts
30.05.13
Marketing or Law
 
3 posts
27.05.13
Capco - how long to hear back?
 
7 posts
11.06.13
Mileage claim Question
 
1 posts
27.05.13
Baringa partners
 
7 posts
29.05.13
Accenture
 
1 posts
27.05.13
Best channel to use to find new role?
 
9 posts
02.01.14
Contractor in your twenties
 
5 posts
13.06.13
Is this normal in consulting?
 
8 posts
17.07.13
Value of CIMA and growth areas
 
7 posts
27.05.13
Early change of location (MBB entry-level)
 
7 posts
27.05.13
Where to start
 
4 posts
27.05.13
Analytics consulting - who does it?
 
5 posts
02.06.13
Building my career/life
 
3 posts
27.05.13
Rejection #6
 
22 posts
05.06.13
Starting a Family as a Consultant
 
9 posts
24.05.13
Should I take this internship?! - help
 
22 posts
25.05.13
Open letter to head hunters...
 
4 posts
31.05.13
Side Ventures - do you have the time or inclination?
 
6 posts
27.05.13
Situational advice
 
5 posts
27.05.13
I need a marketing job in UK
 
6 posts
27.05.13
Leaving consulting? what to do?
 
37 posts
23.05.13
Applying as a Contractor
 
2 posts
27.05.13
moving consultancies
 
2 posts
27.05.13
Is this possible?
 
7 posts
20.05.13
Deloitte Consulting Grades
 
5 posts
27.05.13
Green dot Promotion Ready - definition
 
8 posts
27.05.13
Programme Management or Finance Transformation
 
5 posts
05.06.13
 

Dilemma

 
forum comment
#0 Dilemma
 
Seeker
30.05.13 00:00
 
Hi All,After searching for few months, I have been offered work by two companies .It's a program management position in both cases but there are some differences.First company is a rapidly growing big IT company and has a strong presence worldwide. Has offered me a position of senior consultant in what they call program management consulting area in their investment banking practice. I have only received verbal offer from them and they are in the process of rolling out the formal offer (bureaucracy!). They say it will take some time and joining could be middle of next month. The work is tied to my earlier experience in IT and IB.The second company is a relatively small services company but has been growing well. I have received offer letter for manager position there but , for initial few months, I'm supposed to work as business analyst. I talked to a friend who is working in similar role and he said it's mainly a delivery role. Here the work is in IT but in a totally different domain (which I don't mind). They want me to join next week and have sent me the offer.First company is paying slightly less than the second one. Questions I have are:1. What sort of growth opportunities I can expect in either case ? I don't want to be limited to be a PMO/project manager and I enjoy the technical side of things too.2. I got the job in the second company as I got some good references there from my ex-colleagues from another firm working in it presently. So, if I let go this opportunity, I'd be affecting them too. But I guess I can't dwell on this and should focus on my career. What do you think ?3. First company has told that they are committed to hiring me but lack of a formal offer letter, fixed joining date and fixed project allocation is not really ideal situation. What is your opinion on this ?4. Finally, I want to work in the IT strategy, BTO type of function in the long run. Do you think the above opportunities still leave a scope for that kind of 'exit' ?Appreciate your comments.Seeker
 
Reply

Reply

 
 
forum comment
#0 RE: Dilemma
 
PatrickMcIntyre
30.05.13 00:00
 
Hi Seeker,In my opinion, sometimes words aren't worth very much and a lot can change. So many time's I've heard "I've been offered the job verbally" only to find that very person still job hunting 6 months late.What I'm getting at is that it would be silly, in my opinion, to pass up on an opportunity a friend has gone out of his way to help you gain, based on a verbal conversation.If you take up the second offer and decide you hate it/you'd prefer the first company - if the offer comes, you leave. It's as simple as that.P.S. do not underestimate the power of networking. I'm not saying that you should base your choices around what your friend would prefer, I'm saying that reputations last a long time and word of mouth goes a long way. One day you might need help again so be sensitive :)
 
Reply

Reply

 
Return to the top of page.

ThreadID: 0